Arbitration 2024

[kickthepony (Isotopes)]

If you have been here for an offseason you know the deal, if you're new then read the following. The arbitration numbers we use are taken from mlbtraderumors.com's projections. We do it this early because if you reject a players arbitration, they are eligible for RFA. Doing it this early makes it easier for you to plan ahead, and for us to get an idea of who is going to be a free agent when we set it up. MLBTR is very very on target with their projections, which is why we use them. However they aren't perfect, and at most are about 1 mil off. So to reconcile that, if you accept the number that is posted here and the player ends up settling for less, you will get the lower number. If you accept and the player wins his case and gets more, you will receive the projected number. That way you always get the lower number. You will respond to this post with who you accept or decline or if you want to wait for now. The deadline for this is January 1st. If you decline and want to RFA, go to the RFA thread and post there. If your player signed a contract to avoid arbitration or as an extension, you will pay the AAV of that contract for the remainder of the time that you have control over that player.

Player Name

Arbitration Estimate

Actual Arbitration

Accepted or Declined

Flexon Truthers

Ryan Mountcastle	4.2 mil
Andrew Vaughn	3.7 mil
Jazz Chisholm	2.8 mil
Akil Baddoo	1.7 mil
Justin Dunn	1.0 mil
Luis Patino	1.0 mil
Tanner Houck	1.0 mil
Kyle Funkhouser	1.0 mil
Tony Gonsolin	3.3 mil

                                    
BYSC

Jonathan India	3.7 mil
Leody Taveras	2.4 mil
Casey Mize	1.2 mil
Erik Swanson	2.7 mil

Bombers

Wander Franco lol	1.0 mil
Trent Grisham	4.9 mil
Dylan Carlson	1.8 mil
Kyle Tucker	12.6 mil
Corbin Burnes	15.1 mil
Devin Williams	6.5 mil

Krispy Kremers

Alejandro Kirk	2.6 mil
Luis Garcia	2.4 mil
Alec Bohm	4.3 mil
Bo Bichette	11.2 mil
Isaac Paredes	3.2 mil
Chas McCormick	3.1 mil
Zac Gallen	10.9 mil
Daniel Lynch	1.0 mil

Injured Reserve

Cal Raleigh	1.0 mil
Luis Urias	4.7 mil
Carter Kieboom	1.0 mil
Randy Arozarena	9.0 mil
Daulton Varsho	5.5 mil
Logan Gilbert	4.9 mil
Shane McClanahan	3.6 mil

Weeb Squad

Abraham Toro	1.3 mil
Nick Madrigal	1.9 mil
Trevor Larnach	1.0 mil
Daz Cameron	1.0 mil
Austin Hays	6.1 mil
Ian Anderson	1.0 mil
James Kaprielian	1.5 mil
Tarik Skubal	2.6 mil
Jesus Luzardo	5.9 mil
Duane Underwood Jr	1.0 mil
James Karnichak	1.9 mil

Gauchistas

Danny Jansen	5.2 mil
Andres Gimenez	15.2 mil*
Bryan Reynolds	13.3 mil
Griffin Canning	2.5 mil
Adbert Alzolay	2.5 mil
Nate Pearson	1.0 mil
Eli Morgan	1.0 mil
Brusdar Graterol	2.5 mil

*Andres Gimenez signed deal worth 15.2 AAV

Cub Cobblers

Joey Bart	1.0 mil
Ryan McKenna	1.0 mil
Michael Kopech	3.6 mil
Brady Singer	5.1 mil
David Peterson	2.0 mil
Logan Allen	1.0 mil

SH Aliens

Ryan Jeffers	2.3 mil
Nico Hoerner	11.5 mil*
Jo Adell	1.0 mil
Brandon Marsh	1.0 mil
Victor Robles	2.7 mil
Chris Paddack	4.2 mil
Garrett Crochet	1.0 mil
Wil Crowe	1.0 mil

*Nico Hoerner signed deal worth 11.5 mil AAV

Krustyville

Sean Murphy	12.1 mil*
Lewin Diaz	1.0 mil
Keston Hiura	1.0 mil
Jorge Mateo	2.9 mil
Jesus Sanchez	2.0 mil
Ryan Weathers	1.0 mil
Kyle Wright	1.4 mil
Zach Pop	1.0 mil
Yency Almonte	1.9 mil
Josh Staumont	1.2 mil
Anthony Bender	1.0 mil
Zach Thompson	1.0 mil

*Sean Murphy signed deal worth 12.1 mil AAV

Scrubs

William Contreras	1.0 mil
Bobby Dalbec	1.0 mil
Brendan Rodgers	3.3 mil
Nick Gordon	1.0 mil
Dustin May	2.4 mil
Alek Manoah	1.0 mil

Pin Pals

Pete Alonso	22 mil
Shed Long	1.0 mil
Cavan Biggio	3.7 mil
Ke'Bryan Hayes	8.75 mil*
Kevin Newman	1.0 mil
Taylor Trammell	1.0 mil
Jarred Kelenic	1.0 mil
Kolby Allard	1.0 mil
Mitch Keller	6.0 mil
Triston McKenzie	1.8 mil
Dean Kremer	2.4 mil
Jose Suarez	1.1 mil
Kyle Zimmer	1.0 mil

*Ke'Bryan Hayes signed deal worth 8.75 mil AAV

Isotopes

Tyler Stephenson	2.9 mil
Nathaniel Lowe	8.8 mil
Nick Senzel	3.0 mil
Gavin Lux	1.1 mil
Alex Verdugo	9.2 mil
Dylan Cease	8.8 mil

Golden Dragons

Will Smith	9.3 mil
Josiah Gray	1.0 mil
Taylor Hearn	1.7 mil
Cionel Perez	1.3 mil
Anthony Kay	1.0 mil

Dr Baseball

Zack Collins	1.0 mil
Alex Jackson	1.0 mil
Bobby Bradley	1.0 mil
Vladimir Guerrero Jr	20.4 mil
Yu Chang	1.0 mil
Edwin Rios	1.0 mil
Alex Kiriloff	1.7 mil
Touki Toussaint	1.0 mil
Aaron Civale	4.6 mil
Matt Manning	1.0 mil
Dane Dunning	3.4 mil
Dillon Tate	1.5 mil
Dennis Santana	1.0 mil

Red Squadron

Jake Fraley	2.2 mil
Luis Garcia	2.1 mil
Kyle Muller	1.0 mil
Jonathan Loaisiga	2.5 mil
Ryan Helsley	3.0 mil
Phil Bickford	1.0 mil

[tummysticks17 (Scrubs)]

Accept all

[kickthepony (Isotopes)]

Accept all

[mjm1196 (Injured Reserve)]

Cal Raleigh 1.0 mil (Accept)
Luis Urias 4.7 mil (decline)
Carter Kieboom 1.0 mil (decline)
Randy Arozarena 9.0 mil (accept)
Daulton Varsho 5.5 mil (will decide later)
Logan Gilbert 4.9 mil (accept)
Shane McClanahan 3.6 mil (accept)

[admiraljones42 (S.H. Aliens)]

Accepting -

Ryan Jeffers 2.3 mil
Nico Hoerner 11.5 mil
Jo Adell 1.0 mil
Brandon Marsh 1.0 mil

Garrett Crochet 1.0 mil

Declining -

 

Victor Robles 2.7 mil
Chris Paddack 4.2 mil
Wil Crowe 1.0 mil

[timland33]

Joey Bart 1.0 mil - accept
Ryan McKenna 1.0 mil - accept
Michael Kopech 3.6 mil - accept
Brady Singer 5.1 mil - decline
David Peterson 2.0 mil - decline
Logan Allen 1.0 mil - decline

[omegaman]

Accepting:

Ryan Mountcastle 4.2 mil
Andrew Vaughn 3.7 mil
Jazz Chisholm 2.8 mil
Tanner Houck 1.0 mil
Tony Gonsolin 3.3 mil

Declining:
Akil Baddoo 1.7 mil
Justin Dunn 1.0 mil
Luis Patino 1.0 mil
Kyle Funkhouser 1.0 mil

[clutchyball (B.Y. Soup Cups)]

Accept all

[drag0ng0ld8 (Golden Dragons)]

Will Smith 9.3 mil Accept
Josiah Gray 1.0 mil Accept
Taylor Hearn 1.7 mil Reject
Cionel Perez 1.3 mil Accept
Anthony Kay 1.0 mil Reject

[Avdo (KrispyKremers)]

accept all

[captainsolo96 (Red Squadron)]

Red Squadron


Jake Fraley 2.2 mil accept
Luis Garcia 2.1 mil accept
Kyle Muller 1.0 mil accept
Jonathan Loaisiga 2.5 mil decline
Ryan Helsley 3.0 mil accept
Phil Bickford 1.0 mil accept

[mjm1196 (Injured Reserve)]

Nov 5, 2023 21:50:07 GMT -5 mjm1196 (Injured Reserve) said:

Cal Raleigh 1.0 mil (Accept)
Luis Urias 4.7 mil (decline)
Carter Kieboom 1.0 mil (decline)
Randy Arozarena 9.0 mil (accept)
Daulton Varsho 5.5 mil (will decide later)
Logan Gilbert 4.9 mil (accept)
Shane McClanahan 3.6 mil (accept)

Decline on Varsho

[San Antonio Gauchistas]

Danny Jansen 5.2 mil decline
Andres Gimenez 15.2 mil* decline and RFA
Bryan Reynolds 13.3 mil accept
Griffin Canning 2.5 mil accept
Adbert Alzolay 2.5 mil accept
Nate Pearson 1.0 mil accept
Eli Morgan 1.0 mil accept
Brusdar Graterol 2.5 mil accept

[Eric (Guidopolis)]

Pete Alonso 22 mil Accept
Shed Long 1.0 mil Reject
Cavan Biggio 3.7 mil Accept
Ke'Bryan Hayes 8.75 mil* Accept
Kevin Newman 1.0 mil Reject
Taylor Trammell 1.0 mil Accept
Jarred Kelenic 1.0 mil Accept
Kolby Allard 1.0 mil Accept
Mitch Keller 6.0 mil Accept
Triston McKenzie 1.8 mil Accept
Dean Kremer 2.4 mil Accept
Jose Suarez 1.1 mil Reject
Kyle Zimmer 1.0 mil Reject

[msnmllr - Macho Mania]

Not Krustyville is accepting all